Top 20 Ways to Improve TWH Judging
WalkingHorseChat now has fully functional “Judges Ratings and Reviews” operational and functional. Many judges are already getting positive and negative reviews. The same team that helped design the review system also helped with Top 20 Ways to Improve TWH Judging. Here they are… please comment.
1. Implement standardized training programs for judges that include ethics, rules, and evaluation criteria.
2. Establish a transparent certification process for judges with periodic assessments and re-evaluations.
3. Create a registry of judges with documented education, experience, and performance reviews.
4. Encourage mentorship programs pairing novice judges with experienced judges for guidance and observation.
5. Set up a peer review system allowing judges to evaluate each other’s placements and decision-making processes.
6. Incorporate technology, such as video reviews of classes, to have a second look at placements and enhance objectivity.
7. Employ an anonymous feedback mechanism for competitors and spectators to report concerns about judging integrity.
8. Organize workshops focusing on bias training and conflict-of-interest awareness for judges.
9. Host open forums for judges to discuss experiences and challenges, promoting transparency and collaboration.
10. Utilize a points system for judging decisions that requires justification for placements to discourage arbitrary scoring.
11. Introduce a rotating panel of judges for different shows to mitigate bias linked to specific judges’ preferences.
12. Establish clear guidelines on how to handle disputes concerning judging outcomes, ensuring fair resolution.
13. Promote community engagement by allowing peer feedback from trainers and competitors on judging performances.
14. Integrate video replay into judging panels, allowing judges to review and reconsider placement decisions.
15. Develop a code of ethics that judges must sign, outlining expectations for behavior and integrity in judging.
16. Regularly conduct workshops on anatomy, movement, and breed standards to keep judges informed and current.
17. Collaborate with equine organizations to develop and disseminate best-practice guidelines for assessing conformation and performance.
18. Create an online platform for judges to access resources and participate in discussions about current trends in horse performance evaluation.
19. Encourage judges to attend and participate in major equestrian events to broaden their exposure to different judging styles and competitions.
20. Reward judges for ethical behavior and transparency, reinforcing the importance of honesty in the judging process.
See insights
Boost a post
All reactions:
Leslie Perry Collins, Andy Carter Stables and 4 others